Real Audiencia of Santo Domingo

From Hispanopedia
Real Audiencia of Santo Domingo
Audiencia y Chancillería Real de Santo Domingo de la Isla Española
Museo de las Casas Reales, former seat of the Audiencia and of the Government of Santo Domingo.
ScopeAdministration of justice and governmental powers provided for by the legislation of the Indies
JurisdictionHispaniola and, depending on the period, Cuba, Puerto Rico, Jamaica, territories of Tierra Firme, Florida and Louisiana
Legal basisRoyal Provision of October 5, 1511; Ordinances of June 4, 1528; Royal Decree of October 6, 1861
TypeSuperior court of justice
Legal systemLaw of the Indies; Spanish Overseas legislation during the annexation of 1861–1865
SeatSanto Domingo
PresidencyPresident of the Audiencia; judicial direction in the hands of the Regent in its last stage
CompositionPresident, Oidores, Fiscal and other officials; Regent from 1776. In 1861: Regent, four Magistrates, Fiscal, Deputy Fiscal and Secretary.
Dependent onSpanish Monarchy
Superior bodyCouncil of the Indies during the viceregal era
RelatedCaptaincy General of Santo Domingo
CreatedOctober 5, 1511
Dissolved1865
SuccessorReal Audiencia of Puerto Príncipe; Supreme Court of Justice after the Dominican Restoration
NotesSuspended in 1516 and reestablished in 1520; consolidated as an Audiencia and Chancery in 1526–1528. Moved to Cuba and installed in Puerto Príncipe in 1800. Reestablished in Santo Domingo in 1861.

The Real Audiencia of Santo Domingo, also called the Audiencia y Chancillería Real de Santo Domingo de la Isla Española (Audiencia and Royal Chancery of Santo Domingo of the Island of Hispaniola), was the first collegiate superior court of justice established by the Spanish Empire in America.

Its creation, on October 5, 1511, began the development of the Reales Audiencias of the Indies, which were charged with hearing appeals from the lower courts and exercising other judicial and governmental powers.[1][2]

Its district extended, at different times, over the Antilles and various continental regions. After the cession to France of the Spanish part of Hispaniola, agreed in 1795, the institution was moved to Cuba and continued as the Real Audiencia of Puerto Príncipe. A new Audiencia was established in Santo Domingo in 1861, during the annexation to Spain, and disappeared when the annexation ended in 1865.[3][4]

Creation

Detail of the building.

The origin of the court was linked to the Columbian lawsuits, in which the family of Christopher Columbus claimed the rights and powers granted in the Capitulations of Santa Fe. The conflicts between Governor Diego Colón and the Crown also extended to the administration of justice. The establishment of a court of appeal made it possible to limit the concentration of powers in the Governor and to settle in America matters whose referral to the Peninsula was costly.[5]

The founding provision was issued in Burgos on October 5, 1511 by King Ferdinand the Catholic, who held the Regency of Castile. A Court and Audiencia of appeal was constituted, made up of three judges: Marcelo de Villalobos, Juan Ortiz de Matienzo and Lucas Vázquez de Ayllón. The Ordinances of the same date regulated its proceedings and provided that the authorities should recognize its decisions in the civil and criminal cases submitted to it.[6]

Consolidation

In 1516, the arrival of the Government of the Hieronymite friars was accompanied by the suspension of the Court of Appeal.[7] Licentiate Alonso de Zuazo, appointed Judge of residencia in October of that year, was entrusted with examining the conduct of the appeal judges and of other officials. He arrived in Santo Domingo in April 1517 and also took over the ordinary administration of justice.[8]

The court was reestablished in 1520. A letter from its judges dated August 28 informed the King of the receipt of the order to resume their offices and gave thanks for the addition of a Presidency and of more judges. The Presidency then fell to Pedro Suárez de Deza.[7]

Its consolidation as an Audiencia and Chancery is usually dated to 1526, in connection with the provisions of Charles I of September 14. The Ordinances of June 4, 1528 specified its organization and placed it on an equal footing, in the issuing of royal documents, with the Chanceries of Valladolid and Granada, with the power to dispatch provisions and ejecutorias under the title, seal and register of the Monarch.[7]

On June 28, 1527, Bishop Sebastián Ramírez de Fuenleal was appointed President, with governmental powers. His tenure in Santo Domingo lasted until 1531, when he went on to preside over the Real Audiencia of Mexico.[9]

The instructions addressed to Ramírez de Fuenleal show the Crown's attention to the day-to-day functioning of the court. A Royal Cédula of July 1, 1528 ordered compliance with the new Ordinances, the public holding of the Oidores' hearings and the correction of the excessive fees charged by the Notaries. These were to respect the fee schedules in force while one adapted to the conditions of the island was being prepared.[10]

Evolution

The Royal Cédula of May 23, 1539 separated the Province of Nicaragua from the jurisdiction of the Audiencia of Santo Domingo and attached it to the jurisdiction of the Real Audiencia of Panama.[11]

Rodrigo de Contreras, our Governor of the Province of Nicaragua... as to what you say about which of the Audiencias, that of New Spain or that of Hispaniola, this Governorate shall obey: because, as you will have learned, we have ordered another Audiencia of ours to be established in the City of Panama, and by a provision we ordered that this Province obey the said Audiencia of Panama, you shall see that it is so done and that everything ordered by the said Audiencia of ours is fulfilled and executed in accordance with the said provision of ours.

One of its principal figures, Licentiate Francisco Manso de Contreras, was assigned as Fiscal on April 20, 1602 and sent on the 28th by Royal Cédula, although he was promoted to Oidor on May 19, 1603, serving until 1609.

The Recopilación de Leyes de Indias of 1680, in Law II (Audiencia y Chancilleria Real de Santo Domingo de la Isla Española) of Title XV (De las Audiencias y Cancillerías Reales de las Indias) of Book II, sets out the boundaries and the officials of this Audiencia:[12]

We command that in the City of Santo Domingo of the Island of Hispaniola our Audiencia and Royal Chancery shall reside, as it is founded, with a President, who shall be Governor and Captain General; four Oidores, who shall also be Alcaldes del Crimen; a Fiscal; an Alguacil Mayor, and a Lieutenant of the Grand Chancellor, and the other necessary Ministers and Officials; and it shall have as its district all the Windward Islands, and of the Coast of Tierra Firme, and in them the Governorates of Venezuela, Nueva Andalucía, the Río de la Hacha, which belongs to the Governorate of Santa Marta, and of Guayana, or Province of El Dorado, whatever may fall to it for now, and no more, bordering to the south on the four Audiencias of the New Kingdom of Granada, Tierra Firme, Guatemala and New Spain, following the coasts that run from the North Sea toward the west, on the Provinces of Florida, and for the rest on the North Sea; and the President, Governor and Captain General may order and shall order whatever is fitting in military causes, and in those concerning the good government and defense of the said Island of Santo Domingo, in the same manner as our other Governors and Captains General of the Provinces of our Indies can and must do, and shall fill the governorships and other offices that fall vacant in the district of that Audiencia, until We fill them, and shall do, exercise and provide all other matters of Government, and the Oidores of the said Audiencia shall not intervene in them, nor the President in those of justice, and all shall sign what the Oidores provide, sentence and dispatch.

In expanding the jurisdiction of the Captaincy General of Venezuela, which by that time was already part of the Real Audiencia of Santo Domingo, the Royal Cédula of September 8, 1777 added to it the provinces of Maracaibo and Guayana:

Likewise I have resolved to separate in judicial matters from the Audiencia of Santa Fe, and to attach to the original one of Santo Domingo, the two aforementioned Provinces of Maracaibo and Guayana, as that of Cumaná and the islands of Margarita and Trinidad already are, so that, these territories being under one and the same Audiencia, Captain General and Intendant close at hand, they may be better ruled and governed with greater benefit to my Royal Service.

Organization

The Audiencia administered justice on appeal and heard certain matters at first instance, including the so-called casos de Corte. Its status as a superior court was accompanied by consultative and governmental powers provided for by the legislation of the Indies. The Audiencias could replace the Governors in the cases of vacancy, illness or death contemplated by the laws.[13][2]

In the organization set out in the Recopilación de Leyes de Indias, sanctioned in 1680 and published in 1681, Santo Domingo was an Audiencia presided over by a Governor and Captain General. Law II of Title XV of Book II established a staff of four Oidores, who also served as Alcaldes del Crimen, a Fiscal, an Alguacil Mayor, a Lieutenant of the Grand Chancellor and the remaining necessary Ministers and officials.[14]

The same law distinguished the functions of the President from those of the Oidores. To the former belonged the Government and defense of Santo Domingo, military affairs and the interim filling of vacant offices in the district. The Oidores were to settle matters of justice, without intervening in the matters reserved to the Government; the President, in turn, was to refrain from intervening in the judicial decisions that belonged to them.[14]

Although Santo Domingo was linked to the Viceroyalty of New Spain, its judicial district covered territories with different governmental authorities. The Audiencia also exercised consultative functions in matters of Government and in the oversight of the Real Hacienda. These powers explain its relationship with the Captaincy General of Santo Domingo, whose extent and competences did not necessarily coincide with those of the appellate district.[15][14]

In 1776 the office of Regent was added, as part of the reforms of the Audiencias of the Indies. The Regent directed the internal functioning of the court, coordinated the Oidores and distributed the cases. His conduct was regulated by the Instruction of Regents of June 20, 1776. The first Regent of Santo Domingo was Andrés de Pueyo y Urríes.[16][17]

Jurisdiction

First district

The initial jurisdiction comprised the Castilian possessions in the islands and in Tierra Firme, expanding with the conquests. Hispaniola, Puerto Rico, Jamaica and Cuba were linked to Santo Domingo, as were various regions of Central America and of the northern coast of South America. The creation of the Audiencias of Mexico, Panama, Guatemala and Santa Fe progressively reduced that vast district.[1][5]

One example of these modifications was that of the Province of Nicaragua. The Royal Cédula of May 23, 1539, addressed to Governor Rodrigo de Contreras, confirmed that the Province was to obey the new Real Audiencia of Panama, in accordance with an earlier provision. The document answered the Governor's query as to which Audiencia his Governorate should be subject to.[18]

Law II of Title XV of Book II of the Recopilación described the district by means of the name Windward Islands and the territories of the coast of Tierra Firme. It included the Governorates of Venezuela and Nueva Andalucía, Río de la Hacha, belonging to Santa Marta, and the portion of Guayana or Province of El Dorado that fell to Santo Domingo. It indicated its boundaries with respect to the Audiencias of Santa Fe, Panama, Guatemala and New Spain, the Provinces of Florida and the North Sea.[14]

Venezuela

The relationship with the Venezuelan Provinces underwent successive modifications. The Province of Venezuela returned to the district of Santo Domingo by Royal Cédula of February 12, 1742. Later, the Royal Cédula of September 8, 1777 added Maracaibo and Guayana in judicial matters, separating them from the Audiencia of Santa Fe and joining them with the Provinces and islands that already depended on Santo Domingo.[5]

The reorganization of 1777 unified the governmental and military affairs of those Provinces under the Captaincy General of Venezuela, while appeals went to Santo Domingo. Cumaná, Margarita and Trinidad formed part of this grouping. The creation of the Real Audiencia of Caracas in 1786 established a superior court of their own for the six Provinces of Venezuela, Maracaibo, Cumaná, Guayana, Margarita and Trinidad, which ceased to depend judicially on Santo Domingo.[19]

Florida and Louisiana

In the second half of the 18th century, the incorporation of Louisiana into the Monarchy and the recovery of the Floridas expanded the territorial scope related to the Audiencia. The Floridas came under Spanish sovereignty again in 1783.[13]

Louisiana's link had particular features: before the establishment of the court in Puerto Príncipe, its appeals went through a court of appeals in Havana and, on second supplication, through the Council of the Indies. Its integration into the common judicial system came with the organization of the Audiencia of Puerto Príncipe.[3]

Activity

The court's activity was tied to the conflicts of Government and to the expansion of the Monarchy. During the uprising of Enriquillo in the Bahoruco, the military powers granted to Ramírez de Fuenleal in 1527 defined the authority competent to intervene. When he went to Mexico in 1531, those powers were transferred to the Oidores of Santo Domingo.[9]

Another notable episode was the Devastations of Osorio, carried out at the beginning of the 17th century to combat trade with foreigners by relocating populations from the north and west of Hispaniola. Their implementation provoked clashes between President Antonio de Osorio and Oidores Gonzalo Mejía de Villalobos and Francisco Manso de Contreras. Between 1605 and 1608 there followed accusations, recusals and proceedings against both Magistrates.[20]

Manso de Contreras had been appointed Fiscal in 1602 and Oidor in 1603. He remained linked to the court until his promotion to the Real Audiencia of Panama in 1609. His career makes it possible to observe the conflicts between the obligations of the Magistrates, their family relationships and their economic interests, which were subject to legal restrictions and to the control of the Crown.[21]

Transfer

The Treaty of Basel, signed in 1795, provided for the cession to France of the Spanish part of Hispaniola. The loss of that territory made it necessary to move the Audiencia to Cuba.[15]

The Royal Cédula of May 14, 1797 chose the Villa of Santa María del Puerto del Príncipe, present-day Camagüey, as the new seat. Havana was designated as the provisional seat.[3] The provisions concerning the transfer continued with the Royal Decree of March 17, 1799, and the definitive installation in Puerto Príncipe took place in 1800.[15] The institution was renamed the Real Audiencia of Puerto Príncipe, with a district that comprised Cuba, Puerto Rico, Florida and Louisiana, excluding the Spanish part of Santo Domingo ceded to France.[3]

The district of the Cuban Audiencia was reduced during the 19th century. The Real Audiencia of Puerto Rico, created in 1831 and installed in 1832, gave that island a court of its own.[22] In 1838 the Real Audiencia of Havana was created, while Puerto Príncipe retained the Eastern and Central Departments of Cuba, including the Governments of Trinidad and Fernandina de Jagua.[23] The Audiencia of Puerto Príncipe was abolished in 1853 and its functions passed to Havana.[24]

España Boba

After the Spanish recovery of Santo Domingo in 1809, during the period known as the España Boba, appeals came under the jurisdiction of the Audiencia of Puerto Príncipe. In 1810 it was ordered that civil appeals, criminal consultations and recursos de fuerza in ecclesiastical matters should pass to the Audiencia of Caracas, but the expulsion of the latter's Oidores prevented the change from taking effect. Puerto Príncipe continued to hear the matters of Santo Domingo until December 1821.[25]

The recovery of the territory in 1809 and the application of the Constitution of Cádiz did not entail the reinstallation of an Audiencia in the city. The next creation of the court in Santo Domingo took place in 1861.[25][4]

Reestablishment

During the annexation to Spain, promoted by Pedro Santana in 1861 and recognized by Queen Isabella II, the judicial administration of the territory was reorganized. The Royal Decree of October 6, 1861 created a Real Audiencia in the capital, with the powers provided for the superior courts of the Overseas Provinces.[26]

The staff of the court comprised a Regent, four Magistrates, a Fiscal, a Deputy Fiscal, a Secretary and the necessary auxiliary employees. Eduardo Alonso Colmenares, until then Fiscal of the Audiencia of Havana, was appointed Regent. The same decree established Alcaldías Mayores and Promotorías Fiscales in Santo Domingo, Santiago de los Caballeros, Puerto Plata, La Vega, Azua de Compostela and Santa Cruz del Seibo.[26]

The new organization responded to the judicial system of the 19th century and to the separation between the administration of justice and the Government.[4] The provisions of October 1861 ordered the application of the Spanish Penal Code and commercial legislation, while provisionally retaining the civil law that had been in force during the Dominican Republic. The Audiencia was also entrusted with forming its archive, for which those of Havana and Puerto Rico were to provide it with the certified copies of laws, regulations and other provisions that it requested.[26]

The War of the Restoration, which began in 1863, put an end to the annexation. In 1865 the Spanish Audiencia ceased to exist and the republican judicial organization was restored, headed by the Supreme Court of Justice, whose existence dated back to the Dominican Constitution of 1844.[4][27]

Seat

The Audiencia occupied part of the complex of the Casas Reales, in the Ciudad Colonial of Santo Domingo. The complex consists of two connected wings: one devoted to the Palace of the Governors and the other to the Real Audiencia and Chancery. Its façade preserves heraldic elements related to the Monarchy and to the privileges granted to the island and the city.[28]

The building houses the Museo de las Casas Reales, devoted to the history of Hispaniola and of the Spanish institutions established on it.[29] The documentation of the district preserved in the General Archive of the Indies includes royal provisions, consultations, correspondence, administrative files and accounts of the Real Hacienda, and constitutes a source for the study of justice and Government in the Caribbean and its continental territories.[1]

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 "Audiencia de Santo Domingo". Portal de Archivos Españoles (in español). Ministerio de Cultura de España. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 "Audiencias". Bicentenario de las independencias iberoamericanas (in español). Ministerio de Cultura de España. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 "Audiencia de Puerto Príncipe". Archives Portal Europe (in español). Archivo General de Indias. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 "Cuestiones eclesiásticas: historia institucional de la administración española en Santo Domingo". Portal de Archivos Españoles (in español). Ministerio de Cultura de España. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 López B., Alí Enrique. "Audiencia de Santo Domingo". Diccionario de Historia de Venezuela (in español). Fundación Empresas Polar. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  6. ↑ "Real cédula de Fernando V, dada en Burgos a 5 de octubre de 1511, creando una audiencia en Santo Domingo". Colección de documentos inéditos para la historia de España (in español). Vol. II. Madrid: Imprenta de la Viuda de Calero. 1843. pp. 285–293.
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 Gómez Gómez, Margarita (2014). "La Cancillería Real en la Audiencia de Santo Domingo. Uso y posesión del sello y el registro en el siglo XVI" (PDF). Revista de Humanidades (in español) (22): 17–45. doi:10.5944/rdh.22.2014.14289.
  8. ↑ "Zuazo, Alonso de (c.1470-1539)". Portal de Archivos Españoles (in español). Ministerio de Cultura de España. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 Mira Caballos, Esteban (2022). "La resistencia a la dominación de los indígenas de La Española (1492-1533)". Ciencia y Sociedad (in español). 47 (3): 9–34. doi:10.22206/cys.2022.v47i3.pp9-34.
  10. ↑ "Real Cédula a Sebastián Ramírez de Fuenleal, Presidente de la Audiencia de la Isla Española, sobre varios asuntos". Portal de Archivos Españoles (in español). Archivo General de Indias. July 1, 1528. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  11. ↑ Real Cédula contestando carta del 10 de julio de 1538 al Gobernador de Nicaragua, Rodrigo de Contreras. Toledo, 23 de mayo de 1539.
  12. ↑ Recopilación de las Leyes de Indias (1680). Título Quince. De las Audiencias y Cancillerías Reales de las Indias (PDF) (in español).
  13. ↑ 13.0 13.1 "Audiencia de Santo Domingo". Portal de Archivos Españoles (in español). Ministerio de Cultura de España. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 14.2 14.3 "Libro II, Título XV, Ley II: Audiencia y Chancillería Real de Santo Domingo de la Isla Española". Recopilación de leyes de los reynos de las Indias (PDF) (in español). Madrid: Julián de Paredes. 1681.
  15. ↑ 15.0 15.1 15.2 "Real Audiencia de Santo Domingo: historia institucional". Censo-Guía de Archivos de España e Iberoamérica (in español). Ministerio de Cultura de España. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  16. ↑ Manuel García Arévalo, ed. (2023). España y República Dominicana. Una historia compartida (PDF) (in español). Fundación García Arévalo. p. 239. ISBN 978-9945-9387-0-8.
  17. ↑ "Pueyo Urríes, Andrés de (ca.1714-1786)". Portal de Archivos Españoles (in español). Ministerio de Cultura de España. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  18. ↑ "Real Cédula contestando carta del 10 de julio de 1538 al Gobernador de Nicaragua, Rodrigo de Contreras. Toledo, 23 de mayo de 1539" (PDF). Biblioteca Enrique Bolaños (in español). Colección documental de Andrés Vega Bolaños. May 23, 1539. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  19. ↑ "Audiencia de Caracas". Diccionario de Historia de Venezuela (in español). Fundación Empresas Polar. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  20. ↑ Burset, Luis Rafael (2015). "¿«Cosas indebidas» o «siembra de mala voz»?: Los conflictos internos de la Real Audiencia de Santo Domingo, 1605-1608" (PDF). Clío (in español) (189): 96–153.
  21. ↑ Burset, Luis Rafael (2022). "Las redes comerciales del Licenciado Francisco Manso de Contreras en el Caribe, 1590-1619". Revista ECOS UASD (in español). 29 (24): 15–30. doi:10.51274/ecos.v29i2.pp15-30.
  22. ↑ "Guía educativa del Tribunal Supremo: trasfondo histórico" (PDF). Poder Judicial de Puerto Rico (in español). Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  23. ↑ "Real Decreto sobre el establecimiento de una Audiencia en La Habana y la organización de la de Puerto Príncipe" (PDF). Gaceta de Madrid (in español) (1360). August 7, 1838.
  24. ↑ "Audiencia de Puerto Príncipe: historia institucional". Censo-Guía de Archivos de España e Iberoamérica (in español). Ministerio de Cultura de España. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  25. ↑ 25.0 25.1 "Audiencia de Santo Domingo". Portal de Archivos Españoles. Bicentenario de las Independencias Iberoamericanas (in español). Archivo General de Indias. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  26. ↑ 26.0 26.1 26.2 "Reales Decretos de 6 de octubre de 1861 sobre la administración de justicia y la creación de la Real Audiencia de Santo Domingo" (PDF). Gaceta de Madrid (in español) (286): 1. October 13, 1861.
  27. ↑ "El Judicial, septiembre de 2011" (PDF). El Judicial (in español). Poder Judicial de la República Dominicana. September 2011.
  28. ↑ "Un poco sobre el Museo Casas Reales". Dirección General de Museos (in español). February 2, 2023. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
  29. ↑ "Museo de las Casas Reales". MUSEOSRD (in español). Dirección General de Museos. Retrieved October 5, 2026.
Retrieved from "https://en.hispanopedia.com/index.php?title=Real_Audiencia_of_Santo_Domingo&oldid=1833"